Skip to main content
Sniff
25 products graded

Freshpet

Avg score 55.8
Price range $5.14–$10.99/lb
Score distribution
0
A
3
B
22
C
0
D
0
F
GradeProducts
A0
B3
C22
D0
F0
Median price
$7.27/lb
Forms
dry, wet
Life stages
growth
Recalls (history)
0
None recorded
Most-flagged ingredients in this lineup
25 of 25 Freshpet products contain a flagged ingredient (100%).
  • sodium selenite
    In 25 products (100%)
  • carrageenan
    In 12 products (48%)

All Freshpet products

25
Freshpet Vital Beef & Lamb Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag
64
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Beef & Lamb Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag

$7.63/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Beef & Lamb Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag, Sniff Score 64 of 100, grade B
Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, & Salmon Recipe Puppy Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
61
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, & Salmon Recipe Puppy Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$6.30/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, & Salmon Recipe Puppy Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 61 of 100, grade B
Freshpet Healthy Aging Chicken & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
60
Freshpet

Freshpet Healthy Aging Chicken & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$6.30/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Healthy Aging Chicken & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 60 of 100, grade B
Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, Salmon, & Egg Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, Salmon, & Egg Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$6.30/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken, Beef, Salmon, & Egg Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Healthy & Natural Small Breed Non-GMO Beef, Turkey & Lamb Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Healthy & Natural Small Breed Non-GMO Beef, Turkey & Lamb Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6

$10.99/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Healthy & Natural Small Breed Non-GMO Beef, Turkey & Lamb Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Beef, Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Beef, Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6

$11.99/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Beef, Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Benefits Digestive Health Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Benefits Digestive Health Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4

$9.99/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Benefits Digestive Health Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.75-lb bag, case of 4
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.75-lb bag, case of 4

$6.85/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.75-lb bag, case of 4, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Healthy & Natural Large Breed Fresh Dog Food, 20-lb bundle
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Healthy & Natural Large Breed Fresh Dog Food, 20-lb bundle

$7.09/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Healthy & Natural Large Breed Fresh Dog Food, 20-lb bundle, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Shredded Chicken Recipe with Sweet Potatoes & Carrots Fresh Dog Food, 4.5-lb bag
59
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Shredded Chicken Recipe with Sweet Potatoes & Carrots Fresh Dog Food, 4.5-lb bag

$8.89/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Shredded Chicken Recipe with Sweet Potatoes & Carrots Fresh Dog Food, 4.5-lb bag, Sniff Score 59 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Beef & Bison Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 5-lb roll, 4 count
58
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Beef & Bison Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 5-lb roll, 4 count

$7.60/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Beef & Bison Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 5-lb roll, 4 count, Sniff Score 58 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 11-lb bundle
58
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 11-lb bundle

$6.54/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 11-lb bundle, Sniff Score 58 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag
58
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag

$7.27/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Chicken, Beef, Salmon & Egg Recipe Grain-Free Fresh Dog Food, 5.5-lb bag, Sniff Score 58 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Chicken Recipe with Peas, Carrots, & Brown Rice Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4
56
Freshpet

Freshpet Chicken Recipe with Peas, Carrots, & Brown Rice Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4

$3.32/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Chicken Recipe with Peas, Carrots, & Brown Rice Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4, Sniff Score 56 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken, Beef, Egg, & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8
56
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken, Beef, Egg, & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8

$8.54/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken, Beef, Egg, & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 56 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Turkey Recipe with Carrots, Brown Rice, & Spinach Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4
56
Freshpet

Freshpet Turkey Recipe with Carrots, Brown Rice, & Spinach Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4

$3.50/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Turkey Recipe with Carrots, Brown Rice, & Spinach Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 6-lb roll, case of 4, Sniff Score 56 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Small Breed Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6
56
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Small Breed Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6

$9.99/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Small Breed Fresh Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6, Sniff Score 56 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Wild Alaskan Pollock & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
54
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Wild Alaskan Pollock & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$7.00/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Wild Alaskan Pollock & Salmon Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 54 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6
54
Freshpet

Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6

$10.99/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Homestyle Creations Fresh Chicken & Turkey Recipe Dog Food, 1-lb bag, case of 6, Sniff Score 54 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
53
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$6.30/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 53 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken & Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8
51
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken & Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8

$8.54/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Small Breed Chicken & Turkey Recipe Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 1-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 51 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Vital Benefits Joint Health & Mobility Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4
49
Freshpet

Freshpet Vital Benefits Joint Health & Mobility Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4

$9.99/lbdryFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Vital Benefits Joint Health & Mobility Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb bag, case of 4, Sniff Score 49 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken Recipe with Spinach, Cranberries & Blueberries Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8
48
Freshpet

Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken Recipe with Spinach, Cranberries & Blueberries Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8

$6.30/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Grain-Free Chicken Recipe with Spinach, Cranberries & Blueberries Fresh Refrigerated Dog Food, 2-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 48 of 100, grade C
Freshpet Complete Nutrition Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb roll, case of 8
46
Freshpet

Freshpet Complete Nutrition Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb roll, case of 8

$4.37/lbwetFair evidence
Freshpet Freshpet Complete Nutrition Chicken Recipe Fresh Dog Food, 1.5-lb roll, case of 8, Sniff Score 46 of 100, grade C
Same standards, every brand

Want to see how we graded this?

Every weight, every threshold, every flagged ingredient is published. No black box.

Read our methodology